November 19, 2026
How Do You Implement Unrecordable High-Speed Optical Transmission? What I Learned Reading Up on It
This piece covers how a fiber link is made unrecordable, how the equipment goes in, and where it stops: wide-area links only, with no cover…

By CyberWatch
5 min read
This piece covers how a fiber link is made unrecordable, how the equipment goes in, and where it stops: wide-area links only, with no cover for traffic recorded before installation.
- Unrecordable optical transmission hides a fiber signal so that an intercepted copy holds no data worth storing.
- A 2025 Journal of Lightwave Technology paper demonstrated the method on a 100 Gbps signal over 80 km of standard fiber and found that no usable data can be captured.
- The method installs as an overlay, with one matched unit at each end of a link and no changes to the existing optical transport equipment.
- Protection covers data in transit on wide-area links only, and traffic recorded before installation stays exposed.
- CyberRidge's Carmel, Ciena's WaveLogic Encryption, and ADVA's FSP 3000 ConnectGuard all protect optical links, and they differ in what a tap records (noise or encrypted data) and in line rate.
I used to believe a quiet monitoring dashboard meant nobody was copying my fiber traffic. That belief fell apart when I read how a tap works, because it copies light without cutting the cable and gives the dashboard nothing to show. Implementing unrecordable high-speed optical transmission means placing a matched pair of photonic layer security (PLS) units at the two ends of a fiber link, so that whatever a tap captures in between is noise. PLS protects data on the fiber itself by making the light unrecordable.
What a fiber tap copies and why encryption leaves the copy intact
A fiber tap records traffic by pulling a small share of light out of the cable. A clip-on device bends the cable slightly, and a fraction of the light leaks out where a photodetector can read it. The cable stays uncut and the link keeps running, so the operator sees no outage.
The recorded copy is the real threat, because it can be decrypted later. Executive Order 14412, signed June 22, 2026, names the risk of adversaries harvesting data now and decrypting it later. Encryption leaves that copy intact, so protection lasts only until advanced computational methods can decrypt it. An unrecordable signal changes the outcome of a tap: the attacker collects noise instead of scrambled data, and there is nothing to wait on.
Curious what a practical deployment of physical-layer optical security looks like? That Substack piece walks through the rollout in more detail.
How the signal gets treated between the two units
The implementation I examined spreads the signal across 1.5 terahertz of the C-band, the standard range for long-distance fiber. Optical keys that change every fraction of a second then scramble it. An air-gapped component generates those keys, and they travel inside the light, so nothing stores them. A receiver without the current key sees a wide, featureless band of light.
Noise comes next. The unit adds optical noise until the signal sits below the noise level on the fiber, a condition called negative optical signal-to-noise ratio (OSNR), where OSNR compares signal power with the background noise around it. A tap on that fiber captures light with no pattern to isolate, so nothing remains to store or process later.
The partner unit reverses the process. It holds the matching optical key at the exact moment the light arrives, removes the spreading, and recovers the original data. Intact data therefore exists at the two ends of the link and nowhere in between.
Putting the matched pair beside live equipment
Installation is an overlay: one unit at each end of a link, with no changes to the existing optical transport equipment. The protected channel shares the C-band with conventional wavelengths, including up to five from other vendors' equipment. The developer reports validation on carrier links with Raman and EDFA amplification and multi-vendor equipment.
The rollout described runs about four weeks. The units go in parallel with live traffic and no downtime, and the first job is picking the links that carry the most sensitive data. Non-critical traffic moves through the units in weeks two and three while performance is validated. Critical traffic follows in week four, with monitoring throughout.
Watch to find out how fiber transmission is made physically unrecordable, not just encrypted.
Where unrecordable transmission stops
Unrecordable transmission protects data in transit on wide-area network (WAN) links, the long fiber spans that connect sites, cities, and countries. Local networks inside a building are outside its scope, and so is a compromised server at either end of a link.
A tap that ran before installation also stays in the attacker's archive, so protection starts on the installation date. Distance has a stated limit too: a link runs up to 100 km without amplification, and standard EDFA and Raman amplifiers extend longer spans. The technology complements encryption and post-quantum migration.
Carmel, WaveLogic Encryption, and ConnectGuard side by side
I compared the three on method, line rate, key handling, and installation.
CyberRidge
- Method: Carmel spreads, scrambles, and buries the signal in noise so a tap records noise; CyberRidge's founders co-authored the 2025 paper that demonstrated this at 100 Gbps over 80 km.
- Line rate: CyberRidge lists 100 Gb/s per link over a standard 100 GbE client connection.
- Key handling: CyberRidge describes an air-gapped generator that produces a new optical key every fraction of a second, carried in the light.
- Installation: CyberRidge describes an overlay, one unit per link end, with no changes to existing transport equipment.
- Best fit: WAN links where the recording itself must be prevented, alongside encryption.
Ciena
- Method: Ciena's WaveLogic Encryption applies AES-256-GCM at Layer 1, and Ciena says a tap on an optically encrypted fiber yields undecipherable data.
- Line rate: Ciena's listing of the WaveLogic 5e modem in NIST's validation program gives line rates up to 800G.
- Key handling: Ciena explains that a key exchange generates the shared secret an AES-256 engine uses.
- Installation: Ciena builds the encryption into its 6500 and Waveserver platforms.
- Best fit: operators running Ciena optical transport that want validated, high-capacity encryption.
ADVA
- Method: ADVA's FSP 3000 ConnectGuard encrypts at Layer 1 with AES-256, and ADVA's product page says it supports any protocol at any speed.
- Line rate: ADVA states no single figure and describes full throughput at any speed.
- Key handling: ADVA's launch announcement describes a hybrid key exchange that combines Diffie-Hellman with the McEliece post-quantum algorithm.
- Installation: ADVA integrates ConnectGuard in FSP 3000 muxponders and transponders, with no stand-alone encryption equipment.
- Best fit: operators on ADVA FSP 3000 transport that want post-quantum key exchange in the transponder.
The encryption options leave ciphertext on the fiber, so their protection rests on the key exchange holding up. Carmel leaves noise on the fiber, and CyberRidge says it complements encryption, so the two can share a route.
Which links I would protect first
I would begin with links that carry long-lived secrets across fiber the operator does not control, such as inter-site and inter-datacenter spans. Data an attacker has already harvested can be stored indefinitely, so the spans with the most time-sensitive data deserve the earliest installation dates.
FAQ
Q: How is optical transmission made unrecordable?
A: The signal is spread across a wide band of wavelengths, scrambled with optical keys that change every fraction of a second, and buried in optical noise. A tap on the fiber collects noise with no recoverable data. The partner unit holds the matching key and restores the original signal.
Q: Does unrecordable transmission replace encryption or post-quantum cryptography?
A: No. It complements both. Encryption and post-quantum cryptography protect data where it is stored and processed, while unrecordable transmission prevents a usable recording of the signal on the fiber.
Q: Does unrecordable transmission protect local networks or stored data?
A: No. It protects data in transit on wide-area fiber links between sites. Local networks, endpoints, and stored data stay under their own controls.
Q: How long does it take to deploy CyberRidge's Carmel on an existing fiber network?
A: CyberRidge describes a deployment plan of about four weeks. Carmel first runs in parallel with live traffic with no downtime, non-critical traffic is validated in weeks two and three, and critical traffic moves over in week four.
Q: Does Carmel require replacing existing optical transport equipment?
A: No. CyberRidge describes Carmel as an overlay with one unit at each end of a link, working alongside optical equipment from any vendor. It uses a standard 100 gigabit Ethernet client connection, so routers and switches connect as before.
Q: How does Carmel's line rate compare with Ciena and ADVA optical encryption?
A: CyberRidge lists 100 Gb/s per Carmel link, while Ciena's WaveLogic 5e modem is listed at up to 800G and ADVA describes ConnectGuard as supporting any speed. The three also differ in method, since Carmel leaves noise on the fiber and the other two leave encrypted data.