When a Kind Offer Makes You Feel Old

One day, while he was loading the car trunk with groceries at the supermarket, a young man asked my dad if he needed help.

My parents were active throughout their lives — they played competitive doubles tennis, earned black belts in taekwondo, and were always on the go. They didn't slow down until they reached their 70s. Even then, my father continued playing tennis after my mother sat on the sidelines.As they neared their 80s, my father developed health issues, but he still got around fairly well.

My dad looked surprised and, after the grocery-bag offer, he shrugged and told me later, "I guess I'm at that age now."

Although my dad could still get around, the offers by others to help him suggested he didn't look as able as he thought he appeared. The message came across as: You look like someone who might not be able to manage this alone.

It was around this time that I also saw how much he'd aged. He'd sent me a photo of himself and my mom. He looked tired and suddenly old.

Something told me, "Go see them now." And I did. And I'm grateful to have listened to my inner voice.

That was February 2020 — right before lockdown. I was in California, and my parents lived in Arizona. I didn't know it would be the last time I'd see him. He would be gone by August after a brief battle with multiple myeloma.

The fear of needing help

All of this came back to me when I saw a Reddit thread (which has since been removed) where the poster talked about — not the fear of looking older — but the fear of needing help to do things that once required no thought, like getting out of a chair, driving somewhere, opening a jar, and carrying groceries.

Some comments included remarks about losing independence and dignity. Another talked about an older relative with such poor balance that they'd topple over if someone gently bumped into them. The discussion wasn't about physically demanding tasks, just daily acts we perform throughout the day.

Most of the Reddit replies offered the same answer: stay strong. Train your legs and core, work on your balance, and you'll be spared. My father did all those things for decades. It didn't spare him from being seen as someone who needed assistance.

Training protects what you can do, but it doesn't control how others read you.

These are the activities that led the poster to express the fear of becoming dependent on others. This can also lead to the people doubting their own abilities, where it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy (I talk about this here).

My father was able to do the tasks that this Reddit poster mentioned.But being offered help when he didn't feel he needed it subtly shifted his self-perception to that of a person unable to take care of himself, resulting in his comment, "I guess I'm at that age now."

I remember how sad I felt, like when he made an appointment with a geriatrician for the same reason. Each conversation created a tiny ache in my heart — a reminder that they wouldn't be around forever.

In reality, the people who offered to lend my dad a hand could have unknowingly been contributing to his self-perception. The helpful person was most likely being kind, but the offer could also be what's called "benevolent ageism," where well-intended help is based on an assumption that an older person is less capable.

Similar to being called "sweetheart," the offer is like elder-speak younger people tend to use with older people, especially in a healthcare setting.

As the person commented on Reddit, "I was the help. Do you have someone that would do that for you?"

After decades of being the adult who fixed the problem, the friend who showed up, the child who cared for aging parents — the person others called when they needed something — the reversal is frightening. It disrupts identity.

As someone who's always been the problem-solver, I can't even wrap my head around needing help doing everyday tasks like these.

Being offered help might mean the package looked heavy, or it might mean you looked incapable. When you hire someone, you set the terms. When a stranger offers, you don't, and you can't tell what they're seeing.

It's the fear of losing control over the terms. That uncertainty is the heart of an encounter like the one my father experienced.

The question of interdependence

Total independence is an unrealistic concept. We all rely on mechanics, doctors, spouses, electronics, even delivery drivers and other people who know how to do what we cannot. We don't refer to this as "needing help."

Age changes the emotional meaning attached to the word, however.

We fear losing our independence. I've talked about my fear of freeway driving. It bothers me because it limits my world and where I'm willing to go. My ability to jump in my car and fly down the road isn't something I take for granted anymore.

However, I can call for an Uber. Instead of focusing on being independent, a better frame may be interdependence.

Where independence implies you have to do it all yourself, and dependence means someone else must do everything for you, interdependence is about helping one another at different times in different ways.

In hindsight, maybe my father wasn't giving in to a feeling of helplessness but seeing how the exchange had begun to shift.

When you receive an offer of help from a well-meaning person, keep these in mind:

Separate the offer from the verdict.

A kind offer isn't a judgement on your capabilities.

Decide before you answer

Do you want this help? A warm "Thanks, I've got it" and a "Yes, thank you" are both fine.

Practice accepting small help now

Start while you don't need it, so need doesn't arrive as a crisis.

Stay a helper in other ways

Build your network of mutual help early. This is interdependence in practice.

By staying fit, working on your balance, grip, and doing all the things that keep you strong, when someone offers to help you, you're more likely to have the choice to decline.

What Really Determines How Long You Can Live Independently Sometimes accepting help is how you avoid losing control

Are We Destined To Be Crabby? The difference between a personality trait and a warning sign

Sign up here to receive our free weekly newsletter featuring the best of Crow's Feet: Life As We Age.