Product management, when done right, is the engine that drives innovation, customer satisfaction, and business success. But all too often, its potential is squandered. Organizations unknowingly erode the value of product management, leading to frustration, wasted resources, and missed opportunities.
So what actually kills Product Management in organizations?
Product Manager's Competency Gaps
One of the biggest factors that can undermine product management is when product managers fail to properly engage with key stakeholders to get buy-in on the product vision, strategy, and impact on the business. Without this mindshare and alignment, product initiatives will likely face resistance, delays, and potential failure.
Additionally, product managers who under-manage team expectations around clarity in direction and strategy can cause teams to become rudderless and unfocused. Clear communication of the rationale behind product decisions is essential for keeping teams motivated and productive.
A failure to consistently measure and highlight the value delivered by the team's work is another pitfall. If the benefits and ROI of product efforts are not quantified, it becomes difficult to justify budgets, prioritize initiatives, and earn organizational support.
Some product managers fall into the trap of blindly establishing burdensome processes intended for much larger teams. This can drastically slow down execution velocity for smaller, nimble product teams who need flexibility to move quickly.
Perhaps most critically, when product managers become overly focused on just delivery rather than ensuring work maps to addressing key user problems and creating value, they lose sight of the core premise of product management.
Output without outcome rarely yields successful products.
While it is unfair to say product managers should be superhuman, there is indeed a real need for them to be somewhat well-rounded generalists. Nevertheless over the years, I have observed product managers who possess distinctive strengths in certain faculties to be equally effective as well.
The least effective product manager becomes a postman, leading to the erosion of trust from the organization's leadership eventually.
Organizational Maturity Factors
Even highly competent product managers can struggle when operating within organizations that lack maturity around product management best practices. If senior leadership is not familiar with modern product management and the value it provides, they are more prone to deprioritizing it in favor of antiquated "feature factory" mindsets.
Similarly, when decision makers allow fixed mindsets and assumptions to drive actions rather than adapting strategies based on new data, it prevents product organizations from being nimble and executing based on evidence. This problem is especially accentuated by the "just do what you are told, we know it all because we know the business" mindset.
Cultures that place heavy emphasis on measuring teams solely by outputs like features delivered or sticking to arbitrary timelines, rather than optimizing for business outcomes, inhibit product teams' ability to truly deliver differentiated value.
A project-based execution mentality without continuity and a clear path towards the end-game objective can cause product strategies to become fragmented and disjointed over time as initiatives are blately handled off from one team to the next.
Siloed team structures that create internal competitituon for resources is another anti-pattern that hinders product management by reducing visibility and introducing organizational friction.
What Wakes Organizations Up
Despite these pitfalls, organizations are eventually faced with painful realizations that erode their ability to ignore the need for effective product management:
- Rising product development costs, headcount costs, and bloated teams
- Frequently bursting tech and development budgets
- Consistently missing business targets
- Struggling to keep up with competitors who ship superior products
- High attrition rates as top talent becomes demotivated
When the consequences become severe enough, even change-resistant organizations are forced to reevaluate whether their product management practices (or lack thereof) are truly setting them up to win in their markets.
Addressing these cultural, structural, and competency factors is essential for embedding product management as a strategic driver within organizations that wish to remain innovative and competitive in today's rapidly evolving digital landscape.
An interesting formula I've gleaned from Lenny's Newsletter about how product managers can deliver impact, sums it up pretty much.
Impact = Skill x Environment
Product managers, rise up!
I write to improve the clarity of my thinking and to inspire growth in others. If you enjoyed this article and want to read my serendipitous reflections in your mailbox, sign up here or follow me on Medium.